Should I see it?
No.
Short Review: You could make this film into a drinking game - take a shot every time you get bored.
Kenneth Branagh's adaptation of Anthony Shaffer's stage play is lackadaisical from frame one forward. Branagh direction gets in his own way. From his choice of shots to how he lays out his compositions, the piece is over managed and isn't given the freedom to breathe. Its a remarkable thing to see a film so disturbed by the director's hand. The choices made by Branagh and company are so obtuse I had to check twice to make sure this wasn't cobbled together by student filmmakers. The sets, meant to show a rich man's lonely post modern mansion, look more like backdrops to a Duran Duran video than something a human would actually live in. While this may be the ultimate intent of the designer, they distract from the action taking place on screen. Combined with the bone dry dialog, this whole movie is a like a real crappy piece of conceptual art.*
The adaptation, written by Harold Pinter is as dry as old toast covered in sand and served on a plank of dried balsa wood. Shaffer's play pits two characters, the young, handsome Milo and the aged, wealthy and intelligent Andrew. Milo has run off with Andrew's wife and as come to Andrew's mansion to ask the old man to give the woman a divorce. Andrew has a devious plot for the young actor however and a well conceived plot unwinds. Pinter's takes Shaffer's piece and makes it into an antiseptic bore. By the time the piece picks up some steam, Pinter has asked the audience to sit through an insufferable amount of needless prattling. The characters exhibit no actual human qualities beyond the capacity to speak words and inflect their voices. Michael Caine and Jude Law both seem awkward in their lines and developing their roles. Caine in particular seems off. This is surprising since he can pretty much show up on a set and carry the show. In this instance however, he is clearly not comfortable. He should be quite at home in this film though since this isn't the first time he's been around this material.Back in 1972, Shaffer himself wrote a cleaner and bouncier version that starred Lawrence Oliver and Caine. Caine of course, played the younger role his first time out. The previous version seems like a piece of brilliant cinematic art in comparison to this needless update. The original, directed by Joseph L. Mankiewicz (The Barefoot Contessa, Cleopatra) revels in the play of characters. Branagh's version comes across like someone reading the script to you for ninety minutes.If you have a need to see this film do yourself a huge favor and head down to your local video store, dig around in the dusty portion of the drama section and rent the original. It will cost a great deal less and entertain a great deal more.* - to be fair, all conceptual art is crappy.
Related Reviews:
Michael Caine movies
The Eagle Has Landed (1972)
The Weather Man (2005)
Other Critic's Reviews:
PopMatters
A Nutshell Review
Labels: film, Jude Law, Kenneth Branagh, Michael Caine, movie review
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home